Our Flag Means Research
Page last updated on 9 January 2024 [change log]

Contents

Introduction

What is Our Flag Means Research?

Our Flag Means Research functions as a shared space for the curious side of Our Flag Means Death fandom. It's a hub for all sorts of research that's connected to OFMD and its fandom. The focus or the type of research can be pretty much anything, as long as it's OFMD adjacent.

The level of academic professionalism or seriousness is not that important. The focus is on collecting this type of content in one place and making it accessible to everyone.

We will help those of you who are working on research projects by sharing information of your ongoing surveys, interview invitations and other studies that are looking for participants. We can also run polls to collect data.

We will share links to published results that are hosted somewhere in a way that is accessible to everyone (AO3, personal websites, Google Docs etc.)

Works shared via Our Flag Means Research may include content that is not suitable for children. Anyone submitting works must be at least 18 years old.

Return to Contents

Where to find us?

Return to Contents

Submissions

How do I make a submission?
Leave an ask on Tumblr, send a direct message on Mastodon or contact tikli on Discord. Tell what sort of submission you want to make:
  • Promote your upcoming/ongoing study in order to get more participants.
  • Collect data for your study via Tumblr and Mastodon polls.
  • Promote your published results.
What sort of works can I submit?
We're really not too picky. Survey results, media analysis, interviews, essays, statistical analysis... If it was born out of curiosity and you did it to find out about Something, it probably fits the bill.

We expect your work to be respectful towards others and not born out of malicious intent.

Return to Contents

Policies

Do you focus on or avoid specific characters or ships?
The content we share comes from individual fans who are free to choose their subject however they please. We don't discriminate against any character or ship. Any perceived under- or overrepresentation is due to individual motivation.
What is your tagging policy on Tumblr, Mastodon and Pillowfort?
Submitters can suggest what tags they want to use with their content.

NSFW content will be marked as such on Pillowfort and content warnings will be added on Mastodon when needed. On Tumblr, Community labels will be used when needed. NSFW posts will also be tagged with #ofmdnsfw.

If the content focuses on a specific character(s) / ship(s), the established tags will be used when available.

What is your blocking policy?
As a general rule, the accounts on Tumblr, Mastodon and Pillowfort don't block anyone. However, targeting the accounts with harassment or interfering with the data collection in order to skew the results will lead to a block.

Return to Contents

Who are the people behind this whole thing?

The admin of Our Flag Means Research is tikli. There is also a very loosely organised collective of Izzy enjoyers who are actively doing or planning on doing some research regarding OFMD.

Our previous projects used our personal accounts for data gathering, and that presented a problem with blocked accounts, possibly skewing the samples. A few of us had thought about making a new account for data collection purposes. It made a lot more sense to make just one account that everyone could use.

Our Flag Means Research started out on Twitter, but has since moved on to other platforms.

Despite the origins being in the Izzy corner of the fandom, Our Flag Means Research is for everyone who is interested in doing research about the show and the fandom.

Return to Contents

Publications

Are Trans Headcanons Becoming More Popular Than Canonical Trans Characters?

Data was collected in October 2022.

Pie chart of trans characters and how often they appear in OFMD fanfics.

A look into how often the three most popular trans headcanons (Ed, Stede and Izzy) are tagged on AO3 compared to how many Jim-centric fics there are.

The data was collected and the report was written by @Just_Me_Rae (edited by tikli.)

Open PDF

Return to Contents

Names and Titles Izzy and Stede Use for Edward in Season 1 of OFMD

A donut chart showing names and titles Izzy uses when addressing or referring to Edward in Our Flag Means Death season 1.

The different names and titles used when:

  • Izzy Hands refers to Edward Teach or addresses him directly
  • Stede Bonnet refers to Edward Teach or addresses him directly
  • Edward Teach addresses Izzy Hands directly

The data was collected and turned into charts by tikli.

Open PDF

Return to Contents

Ship Tags and Ratings of OFMD Fanfiction on AO3

Data was collected in November 2022.

A stacked area chart showing the number of fanfics featuring the most frequently tagged OFMD ships on AO3.

Curious about what the most frequently tagged OFMD ships are on AO3? Do some ships have more E rated fics than others? How do canon ships compare to non-canon ships?

The data was collected and the report was written by tikli.

Open PDF

Return to Contents

Ship Tags and Ratings of OFMD Fanfiction on AO3 (2023 Rerun)

Data was collected in November 2022, August 2023 and November 2023.

A grouped bar chart showing the most frequently tagged ships and increase in number of fanfics over time for each ship.

An updated look into the most frequently tagged OFMD ships on AO3 a year after the previous study and roughly a month after season 2 finale.

The data was collected and the report was written by tikli.

Open PDF

Return to Contents

Swearing in Our Flag Means Death

A donut chart showing how all swearing in Our Flag Means Death season 1 is distributed between different rude words.

Swearing in Our Flag Means Death: How characters swear in season 1.

The data was collected by ‪bttrgaythndead‬ and turned into charts by tikli.

Open PDF

Return to Contents

To Block or Not to Block: That Is the Survey

Data was collected in November 2022.

Stacked bar chart of different types of background checks and how often they were carried out.

The spark for this survey came from observing the discourse around blocking in the Our Flag Means Death fandom on Twitter. The objective was to find out how Twitter users utilised blocking as well as what thoughts they had about blocking and getting blocked.

In addition to getting an overall view on Twitter users’ blocking behaviour, the survey aimed to find an answer to the following questions:

  • Are there differences in blocking behaviour between the OFMD fandom and other fandoms on Twitter?
  • Are there differences in blocking behaviour within the OFMD fandom, between the fans who have a positive attitude towards Izzy Hands (“Canyonites”) and those with a neutral/negative attitude towards him (“Non-Canyonites”)?
  • Do pro-shippers and anti-shippers block differently?
  • Do fandom Twitter users block differently than those who are not in any fandoms?

The survey was conducted and the report was written by tikli.

Open PDF

Return to Contents

Why Do We Relate to Izzy Hands?

Data was collected in June 2022.

Radar chart of the relatability profile.

A survey report on why fans of Izzy find him so relatable. The data was collected in June 2022, so this is the consensus after season 1 of OFMD.

The survey was conducted and the report was written by tikli.

Open PDF | Read plain text version on AO3

Return to Contents

Why Do We Like Izzy Hands?

Data was collected in September 2022.

Stacked bar chart of the relevancy distribution of answers in seven groups of reasons.

A survey report on why fans of Izzy like him.

The survey was conducted and the report was written by tikli.

Open PDF | Read plain text version on AO3

Return to Contents

How Did Season 2 Affect the Numbers of OFMD Fanfiction on AO3

Data was collected in August-November 2023.

A bar chart showing the weekly numbers of new fanfics before, during and after OFMD season 2.

A report on how the new season affected the numbers of OFMD fanfic. Includes an overall view of the total change between 30 August and 29 November 2023. There's also comparison between the two weeks that followed the teaser trailer and the two weeks that followed the actual trailer. Weekly changes are observed between 14 September and 29 November 2023. The report also looks into how the most popular ship tags fared during this time.

The data was collected and the report was written by tikli.

Open PDF

Return to Contents